Table 1

Reviewed articles with details of return to sport and patient satisfaction

TreatmentAuthor, yearGRADE qualityPatient numberAge (mean)f/u, avgReturn to sport(%)Satisfied patients(%)
Non-operativeSallay, 19963Very low540 yearsNR0/50(1/5)20
Kurosawa, 199622Very low128 years7 years(1/1)100NRNR
Gidwani, 200711Very low122 years2 years(0/1)0(0/1)0
Hoffman, 201410Low1759 years31 months(12/17)71NRNR
OperativeIshikawa, 198821Very low122 years53 months(1/1)100NRNR
Blasier, 199016Very low131 years3 years(1/1)100NRNR
Orava, 19952Very low447 years48 months(1/1)100(3/4)75
Kurosawa, 199622Very low125 years12 months(1/1)100(1/1)100
Klingele, 20021Very low7NR34 monthsNRNR(6/7)86
Chakravarthy, 200514Very low1NR>12 months(1/1)100NRNR
Brucker, 200513Very low537 years>20 months(4/5)80(5/5)100
Folsom, 200824Low2044 years14 months(15/20)75(19/20)95
Mica, 200915Very low658.94 years31.8 monthsNRNR(6/6)100
Floor, 201017Very low244.5 years16 months(2/2)100(2/2)100
Konan, 201025Very low929.212 months(9/9)100NRNR
Kwak, 201123Very low220 years1 year(1/2)50NRNR
Cotofana, 201218Very low149 years1 year(1/1)100(1/1)100
Chahal, 201226Low1244.636.9 monthsNRNR(12/12)100
Sonnery-Cottet, 201220Very low124 years11 months(1/1)100NRNR
Rust, 201419Low5149.8 years45 monthsNRNR(47/51)92
Barnett, 201512Low3644.3 years53.6 monthsNRNR(35/36)96
Subbu, 20154Low7829.7 years2 years(77/78)99NRNR
  • NR, not reported.